I hear what you are saying Scott. I guess my issue with this project is that someone else put in the time and effort to come up with a creative way of representing what their client has asked for and then a competitor comes along and want someone else to duplicate exactly what has been done. I understand that a paying client should get what they ask for, but this isn't a personal project so I don't have a say in the cost nor am I able to persuade the client to take a different approach. They like what they see and they want it for their site.
As far as people duplicating a distinct style such as Alex Roman, I don't consider these people artists. It is good to get inspired by his work since it is truly amazing, but to blatantly come out and say, "I based this image off of what I have seen (name artist here) do" is kind of sad....especially when there is a "Making Of" for the project. There are many artists on this site as well as others that I look up to for inspiration and those are the artists that make this field fun to be in. They are the ones pushing ideas and techniques that allow for advances in this over-saturated field that we are all a part of.