Jump to content

Video Card comparison


Recommended Posts

Okay, so we've seen the benchmarks for the new geforce fx cards and that's all fine and dandy if you want to play games with them but what about actually working with them. I mean how do they compare to the "proffesional" cards like the quadro 750 or 900?

 

Also, I understand that there will be a quadro fx but when? and for how much? I really like the price of the geforce fx at $399. I'm guessing the quadro fx will be around $1000. I'm in the market for a new system so I guess my question is do I go with the geforce fx now (well, soon anyway) or wait for the quadro version and will whatever price difference there is be justified by the extra power? Keep in mind I care a lot more about being able to freely navigate through large complex scenes than I do about AA/AF and such things.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You can also softquadro the Geforce 4 ti's into Quadro's...its not 100% as fast as a quadro, but its close, and helps with certain types of scenes and what not.

 

As for the FX...here's some quick points.

 

1) Its excessively loud...so much so that it even annoys john carmack. In some cases the addition of the card to a computer system results in the video card producing more noise then the rest of the system combined.

 

2) Its got some initial driver bugs. AA isn't working right, as well as some other tearing issues.

 

3) Overall, its only 10% faster then the nearest competition (the 9700 pro) at almost a 150 USD higher price.

 

Positives? It looks damn cool. The drivers will get better, and the performance will get better. Will it get quieter? Nvidia claims the shipping version is quieter, but its reported to still be loud enough to hear over the rest of the computer.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...
Originally posted by Greg Hess:

You can also softquadro the Geforce 4 ti's into Quadro's...its not 100% as fast as a quadro, but its close, and helps with certain types of scenes and what not.

 

Greg, how can I do this??
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hmm... Good question. I don't quite know the URL offhand...just that its possible. Since the Geforce4/Quadro4's actually have different transistor counts, I didn't follow the softquadro scene like I did with the earlier cards.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Softquadro Link:

 

http://www.guru3d.com/comments.php?category=1&id=749

 

I installed last night, works great. Very Important point, you need to patch, and install drivers older than 41.03, as per the directions. You also need to get the Maxtreme drivers from Nvidia's website...

 

Quick breakdown(see quadro link for details):

1. install riva tuner and quadro patch data

2. unpack(don't run) Nvidia drivers older than 41.03

3. run riva tuner and patch the drivers/card

4. uninstall current driver

5. reboot, and install patched drivers manually(thru windows new hardware)

6. card should id as quadro

7. install maxtreme

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I patched a ti4600. The performance increase is nice!

 

Here are some quick benchmarks I did. I don't know if timing is revealing for each of the cases, as some of the times are similar. However, you can clearly see that in some cases, the patch is a big win.

 

Benchmark File, OpenGL(sec), Maxtreme(sec)

 

wireframe2, 75, 29

4view, 10, 5

8omni, 3, 3

dualplanes, 28, 28

geometry1, 29, 5

transparency, 19, 9

texture2, 19, 17

 

Paul

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...